Motor starter: NEMA sizes, IEC ratings, and what to read off the old one before you replace it

November 17, 2026
Allen-Bradley 509-AOD NEMA size 0 motor starter with a 120 V coil standing on a steel workbench
Published on  Updated on  

The request I get most about a motor starter is one line long: "need a starter for a 15 hp motor." No voltage, no coil voltage, no picture of what's in the panel now. That isn't enough to pick one. A 15 hp motor needs a NEMA size 3 on 208 V and a size 2 at 240 V or 480 V. The coil has to match the control circuit. And if the old unit is part of a listed combination, another brand's contactor can quietly break the rating of the whole assembly.

So here's how I read an old starter and size the new one, NEMA or IEC, with the numbers that actually decide it.

What a motor starter is, and what it isn't

A motor starter is a contactor plus an overload relay. The contactor makes and breaks motor current when its coil is energized. The overload relay watches that current and opens the coil circuit when the motor runs hot for too long. That's the whole definition.

A contactor alone has no idea what the motor is drawing, so it isn't a starter. Neither is a breaker. The NEC wants four functions in a motor branch circuit: a disconnect, short-circuit and ground-fault protection, a controller, and overload protection. A plain magnetic starter covers the last two. The first two come from a fused disconnect or a breaker upstream. Put all four into one listed assembly and you have a combination starter.

Motor branch circuit diagram showing which parts make a contactor, a motor starter and a combination starter

Four functions, three names: a contactor covers one, a starter two, a combination starter all four in one listed assembly.

 

Type

What's inside

What it doesn't do

Magnetic starter

Contactor, overload relay, coil for remote or PLC control

No disconnect, no short-circuit protection

Manual starter

Hand-operated switch with overload protection

No remote control; standard versions have no undervoltage release

Combination starter

Disconnect, fuses or breaker, contactor and overload in one listed assembly

Nothing missing; on Types D, E and F the parts are tied to the listing

Reversing starter

Two interlocked contactors, one overload relay

Same gaps as a magnetic starter

Type E self-protected

One device doing disconnect, short-circuit and overload protection

Manual versions need a contactor added for remote start (that pair is Type F)

Compact electronic starter

Contactor and electronic overload in one module

Small motors only (the M100 tops out at 23 A)

Motor starter types and what each one leaves to other parts of the panel

NEMA motor starter sizes: read horsepower at your voltage

NEMA sizes run from 00 to 9. Each size has a continuous current rating and a maximum horsepower at each voltage, and you need both. Motor hp at your voltage can't go over the size's rating, and motor full-load amps can't go over its continuous current.

NEMA size

Continuous amps

200 V (208 V)

230 V (240 V)

460 V (480 V)

575 V (600 V)

Plugging or jogging, 460 V

00

9

1.5

1.5

2

2

1.5

0

18

3

3

5

5

2

1

27

7.5

7.5

10

10

5

2

45

10

15

25

25

15

3

90

25

30

50

50

30

4

135

40

50

100

100

60

5

270

75

100

200

200

150

6

540

150

200

400

400

-

7

810

-

300

600

600

-

NEMA sizes 00 to 7, maximum three-phase horsepower. Plugging and jogging ratings are shown for sizes 00 to 5

 

The 200 V column is the one that bites. A size 2 handles 15 hp at 240 V but only 10 hp at 208 V, so the same motor moves up to a size 3 in a building on 208 V service. I have watched that exact mix-up more than once: right size on paper, wrong voltage column.

The last column is for anything that jogs, inches or plugs. Plugging means reversing a running motor by throwing it straight into the other direction, and the contacts end up breaking stalled-motor current over and over. NEMA cuts the ratings hard for that duty: at 460 V a size 2 drops from 25 hp to 15, a size 1 from 10 to 5. A conveyor somebody inches into position all shift is the same kind of duty, whatever the drawing calls it.

Replacing a NEMA motor starter with an IEC contactor

IEC contactors are rated by utilization category instead of size. AC-3 is ordinary motor duty: start a squirrel-cage motor and switch it off once it's up to speed. AC-4 is starting with inching and plugging. Match the motor to the AC-3 horsepower table, not to the amp number on the front.

Take a 10 hp motor at 460 V. A NEMA size 1 is a 27 A device. An Allen-Bradley 100-C16, a 16 A frame, carries the same 10 hp at 460 V. Move to 230 V and the 100-C16 is good for 5 hp while the size 1 still does 7.5, so there you need a 100-C23. Different voltage, different frame.

NEMA size

hp at 230 V

100-C at 230 V

hp at 460 V

100-C at 460 V

00

1.5

100-C09 (2 hp)

2

100-C09 (5 hp)

0

3

100-C12 (3 hp)

5

100-C09 (5 hp)

1

7.5

100-C23 (7.5 hp)

10

100-C16 (10 hp)

2

15

100-C43 (15 hp)

25

100-C37 (25 hp)

3

30

100-C85 (30 hp)

50

100-C72 (50 hp)

Smallest Allen-Bradley 100-C contactor that matches each NEMA size by AC-3 horsepower

Three things catch people after the swap:

1.    The IEC contactor needs its own overload relay. NEMA heater elements don't carry over, and the IEC relay has a dial you set to motor FLA instead. What that dial really means is in my thermal overload relay article.

2.    If the motor jogs or plugs, size from the AC-4 rating, not the AC-3 one.

3.    The short-circuit rating depends on what sits in front of the contactor. Check the fuse class and size, or the breaker size, that the maker lists for the new contactor. The fuses that protected the old NEMA starter aren't automatically on that list.

 

Allen-Bradley 509-AOD NEMA size 0 starter next to a 100-C09 IEC contactor, both rated 5 hp at 460 V

Both rated 5 hp at 460 V: a NEMA size 0 starter (left) and a 100-C09 contactor (right). Only the 509-AOD comes with an overload relay.

 

What to read off the old motor starter before you pull it

Before the old unit comes out, I write down six things. Five minutes with a flashlight beats a second trip.

1.    The complete catalog number off the label, suffix and all.

2.    The NEMA size, if it's printed. If it isn't, the catalog number usually gives it away.

3.    Coil voltage and frequency, printed on the coil itself. Then measure what the control circuit actually feeds it.

4.    Overload type: heater elements with a code stamped on them, an adjustable bimetal dial, or an electronic relay with an FLA range.

5.    Auxiliary contacts: how many, N.O. or N.C., and what's landed on them. The 3-wire holding contact and the PLC run signal live here.

6.    What sits upstream in the same enclosure. A disconnect handle, fuses, a breaker or an MCP means you're replacing part of a combination, not a standalone starter.

 

Plus the motor nameplate: hp, voltage, FLA, service factor.

Allen-Bradley Bulletin 509 is the one I see most. Its catalog number carries the size, the enclosure and the coil:

Position

Example

Meaning

Bulletin

509

Non-reversing starter (505 is the reversing version)

NEMA size

B

T = 00, A = 0, B = 1, C = 2, D = 3, E = 4, F = 5

Enclosure

O

No enclosure (open type)

Coil

D

120 V 60 Hz. Others at 60 Hz: J = 24 V, H = 208 V, A = 240 V, F = 277 V, B = 480 V, C = 600 V

Overload

A2E

Solid-state overload relay, adjustable 1.0 to 5.0 A. No overload code means a eutectic alloy relay that takes three heater elements

Option

17

Surge suppressor on the coil

Decoding an Allen-Bradley Bulletin 509 catalog number, using 509-BOD-A2E-17

Heater elements are where conversions go sideways. The code stamped on a heater maps to a motor FLA range only in that maker's heater table, for that overload relay. Pick heaters from the table by nameplate FLA. Never copy a number off another brand's heater and hope.

The coil runs on control voltage

Most replacement mistakes end up at the coil. It matches the control circuit; the motor voltage doesn't enter into it. A 480 V motor with a 120 V coil is normal when the panel has a control transformer. Without one, that 120 V coil has nothing to run on. Put a 480 V coil on a 120 V circuit and it never pulls in. Do it the other way around and it burns.

When coils keep burning on the same starter, I measure coil voltage during pickup before ordering another. An AC coil draws far more to pull in than to hold: a 100-C09 takes about 75 VA to close and 9.5 VA to stay closed, and it's only rated to pull in between 85 and 110 percent of coil voltage. If the voltage sags, or the armature sticks and never seals, the coil sits near that pull-in level and cooks.

Flowchart for sizing a replacement motor starter from motor nameplate, duty, voltage, coil and combination type

The replacement check in the order I run it.

 

Combination motor starter: the listing matters more than the parts

A combination motor starter puts the disconnect, the short-circuit protection, the contactor and the overload in one assembly. UL sorts them by how the short-circuit part is done, and that letter matters the day you replace something inside.

Type

Disconnect and short-circuit protection

Listed combination required?

A

Disconnect switch and fuses

No

C

Inverse-time circuit breaker

No

D

Instantaneous-trip breaker (motor circuit protector, MCP)

Yes

E

Self-protected controller doing all four functions in one device

Yes

F

Type E manual self-protected controller plus a contactor

Yes

Combination starter construction types (Type B is no longer made)

Types D, E and F have to be applied as a listed combination under NEC 430.52, and the listing names specific part numbers. On a Type D starter the contactor and the overload are part of that rating. Swap in another brand's contactor because it was on the shelf and the assembly no longer matches its listing, even if it runs fine. Types A and C can be built from parts on their own ratings, so a like-rated contactor is an ordinary repair. The exception is a panel whose SCCR was built on a combination rating; then the listed parts matter there too.

Only Type E is tested to go straight back into service after clearing a short circuit. The others, F included, can be damaged doing their job. After an MCP trips on a real fault, look at the contactor before you reset and walk away.

Manual, reversing and compact starters

Manual motor starter

A manual motor starter is a switch with overload protection: push buttons or a toggle on the cover, no coil, no remote control. Small pumps, fans, compressors, table saws. Watch what happens on a power loss. A standard manual starter has no undervoltage release, so the contacts stay closed through the outage and the motor restarts on its own when power comes back. In Allen-Bradley's 609 family the undervoltage coil comes on the 609U and 609TU versions. On anything with an exposed blade, that's the one I want.

Reversing motor starter

Two contactors, interlocked so both can't close together, and one overload relay. One of the contactors swaps two phases to run the motor backward. If the machine reverses while it's still turning, size from the plugging column in the NEMA table above.

Compact electronic starters

For small motors there are single-module starters with the overload built in. Allen-Bradley's M100 comes in two frames, 0.75 to 9 A and 4.6 to 23 A, works up to 480 V, trips at class 10, and has reversing and non-reversing versions. As a stand-in for an old size 1, check motor FLA against that 23 A ceiling first.

When the "bad" motor starter isn't bad

A lot of starters leave the panel labeled "bad" when the overload just did its job. The new one trips the same way a week later. Before I order anything, I clamp each phase with the motor running and compare it to nameplate FLA. Uneven phases point at the supply or the connections: a loose lug, a worn contact pole. Balanced but high points at the load or the motor itself. If the windings are in question, meg the motor before blaming anything in the panel.

Pitted or welded contacts and a burned coil are real starter failures. A trip at full load usually isn't one.

FAQ

What is the difference between a motor starter and a contactor?

A starter is a contactor with an overload relay attached. The contactor switches the motor, the overload relay keeps it from cooking under a sustained overload. A contactor alone switches heaters, lighting, or motors protected somewhere else, such as by a drive.

What size motor starter do I need for a 10 hp motor?

At 460 V or 575 V, a NEMA size 1. At 230 V or 240 V, size 1 tops out at 7.5 hp, so go to a size 2. At 208 V a size 2 is rated exactly 10 hp. For jogging or plugging duty, go by the plugging ratings: at 460 V that means a size 2 for 10 hp.

Can I replace a NEMA starter with an IEC contactor and overload relay?

Yes. Go by AC-3 horsepower at your voltage and add an overload relay set to motor FLA. A 100-C16 matches a size 1 at 460 V but not at 230 V. Confirm the new contactor's fuse or breaker limits too.

Does a motor starter protect against short circuits?

A standard magnetic starter doesn't. The overload relay reacts to sustained overcurrent over seconds or minutes, not to a fault. Short-circuit protection comes from fuses or a breaker upstream, or from a combination starter that has them built in.

Why does my motor starter coil keep burning out?

Usually the coil voltage doesn't match the control circuit, the control voltage sags at pickup, or the armature isn't sealing and the coil stays near its inrush draw. Put a meter on the coil terminals while it pulls in; that one reading usually tells you which.

Before you order a replacement motor starter

If what's coming out of the panel is an Allen-Bradley 509, match the size letter and the coil letter and you are most of the way there. IQElectro carries most of that range: the 509-TOD (size 00), 509-AAD (size 0 in a Type 1 enclosure), 509-BOD, 509-COD, 509-DOD, 509-EOD and 509-FOD, plus the 505-BOD reversing starter and the 609-BAW manual starter. For an IEC conversion there are 100-C09D10, 100-C16D10 and 100-C85D10 contactors, 193-T1AC16 and 193-EEFD overload relays, and 140M-C2E-C16 motor protection circuit breakers for the short-circuit side.

Published on  Updated on